We will be judging ice cream at different places and posting our ratings. We will rate our experience based on: taste, customer service, appearance of product, value and ambience of location. Each category will have a rating between 0 (very dissatisfied) and 5 (very satisfied). We will calculate the average and award each location with 0-5 scoops of ice cream.
Business Insider- believes the best flavour of ice cream is Mint Chocolate Chip. What do you think? One of our judges would give that honour to Black Currant.
We visit Home County Music and Art Festival and try Homemade European Ice Cream. Will it taste different from mass produced ice cream? How will it rate? Find out as Chris, Lynne and Jeff judge M&R Orchards Homemade ice cream.
The Rating:
Chris
Lynne
Jeff
Taste
Irish Whiskey
4.5
Blue Sky
3.5
Chocolate
3
Avg 3.7
Irish Whiskey
4.5
Blackcurrant
5
Chocolate
3.5
Avg 4.3
Irish Whiskey
3
Vanilla
3
Avg 3
Appearance
4.5
4
4
Value
4
5
4
Customer
Service
4
4
5
Ambiance
4
5
3
Total
20.2/25
22.3/25
19/25
Comments:
Blackcurrant was delicious- tart on the tongue
Whiskey Cream was smooth and mellow
Blue Sky tasted like icing
Customer Services was high- vendor knew about product and answered questions about flavours
Appearance of product was excellent- the small consisted of 3 small scoops of ice cream, very colourful
The special consisted of 2 scoops, whip cream and choice of sauce; however the sauce may have taken away from the flavours of the ice cream
Price of ice cream was excellent $3.50 for 3 scoops in a waffle cone
Today for the ice cream blog, we visit Angelo's and experience Gelato. For those of you don't know, Gelato is an Italian word for ice cream. It is made with milk cream, sugars and fresh fruit. Unlike traditional ice cream, Gelato contains little or no air.
Here is a look at the delicious Gelato displayed at Angelo's.
So the big question- how does it compare to traditional ice cream and frozen yogurt. Let's find out. Each of the judges today get two scoops and two flavours.
The Rating:
Jeff
Lynne
Chris
Elinore
Flavour
Vanilla
Mixed Berry
Peach
Chocolate
Tiramisu
Chocolate
Stratwberry
Peach
Taste
4
5
4.5
5
Appearance
4
5
5
5
Value
4
4
4
4
Customer
Service
4
5
5
5
Ambiance
4
4
4
4
Total
20/25
23/25
22.5/25
23/25
Comments:
The appearance of the Gelato display is a work of art; bright colours, swirls, cookies and fruit
Chunks of Peach give the Gelato that extra taste
All the gelato we tasted seemed to be more flavourful than regular ice cream, and the majority of us thought it was better than frozen yogurt.
Customer service was superb; the server noticed we were having difficulty making a decision on what to get; She suggested trying a couple of flavours
The cost is a little on the higher side; costing $3.99 for two regular scoops
Today we visit Lexington (Michigan) and try the ice cream at Market Place. Located on Main Street in Lexington, this location offers the old fashioned ice cream parlor setting next to an Antique Shop and Night to Remember B&B
The Rating:
Jeff
Lynne
Chris
Flavour
Almond Joy
Michigan
Black Bear
Mackinac Fudge
Taste
3
5
4
Appearance
5
5
4
Value
5
4
4
Customer
Service
5
4
4
Ambiance
4
5
4
Total
22/25
23/25
20/25
Comments:
Unique Flavours such as Michigan Black Bear (a blend of Cherry and Chocolate)
The Almond Joy Flavour had very few almonds
Mackinac Fudge had lots of chocolate fudge
Cute store with depression glass and an old fashioned ice cream parlour feeling
The New Ice Cream Season Begins- 1st Stop: Kiwi Kraze
It is time again for the Best Ice Cream Challenge. Last year the winner was Moo Moo's (in Strathroy). Who will win this year? We will have to wait and see.
To launch the new ice cream season (and in association with One Day) we visit Kiwi Kraze. We have a number of guest judges on this visit- including Leanne, Hayley and Layton. Once again we go to Kiwi Kraze on Tuesday for their 2 for 1 special.
The Rating:
Jeff
Lynne
Elinore
Chris
Taste
4
5
5
4
Appearance
5
5
5
4
Value
4
4
NR
3
Customer
Service
4
4
4
4
Ambiance
3
4
3
3
Total
20/25
22/25
17/20
18/25
Susan
Leanne
Hayley
Layton
Taste
5
5
5
5
Appearance
5
5
5
5
Value
4
4
NR
NR
Customer
Service
4
4
4
4
Ambiance
4
4
4
4
Total
22/25
22/25
18/20
18/20
Comments:
It was too crowded because of the 2 for 1 deal
The Air Conditioning was also too cold for a number of our judges
The cost remains high- without the 2 for 1 deal our average cost would have been $7 each
They need to work hard to lower the price and provide customers with a better value; perhaps offering certain toppings free (hot fudge, whip cream basic sprinkles etc..) that the customer can put on after paying.
They should build a patio, so people can enjoy their frozen yogurt outside